Understanding the Exercise Gender Gap: How Women Benefit More with Less

Understanding the Exercise Gender Gap: How Women Benefit More with Less

A recent trailblazing study by the Smidt Heart Institute at Cedars-Sinai has shed light on the gender disparities in the world of exercise, revealing that women may require less frequent exercise than men to achieve greater cardiovascular benefits.

Historically, data shows that women have been less engaged in significant exercise compared to men. However, this study suggests that women may, in fact, derive more value from each minute of moderate to vigorous activity than their male counterparts.

Unpacking the Data

The study delved into data from over 400,000 U.S. adults, obtained from the National Health Interview Survey database. The participants, of which 55% were female, provided survey information on their leisure-time physical activity from 1997 to 2019.

The analysis revealed that engaging in regular physical activity reduced mortality risk for all adults when compared to being inactive. However, the benefits showed substantial variation between genders concerning the amount of exercise necessary to reach the peak survival benefit.

Conclusions From the Study

This study challenges the traditional one-size-fits-all approach to exercise. Here are some takeaways from the research.

1. Most Men and Women Experience Exercise differently.

Women can benefit more from less frequent exercise compared to men. This discovery is ground-breaking as it empowers women to maximize their health benefits from exercising without having to match the intensity or duration commonly prescribed for men.

2. Fitness Is Not A Numbers Game

For too long, fitness has been viewed as a numbers game — the more hours you put in, the better the results. However, this study challenges this notion, especially for women. Women achieved the same survival benefits with around 2 1/2 hours per week of aerobic activity as men did with five hours per week. This discovery underlines the importance of quality over quantity when it comes to exercise, particularly for women.

3. Tailoring Exercise Regimes: A New Era

This study marks the beginning of a new era in fitness, one where exercise regimes are tailored to individual needs rather than generalized guidelines. The findings highlight the need for fitness professionals to adapt their programs to cater to women's unique needs, thereby maximizing the benefits they can derive from each workout session.

4. The Power of Regular Exercise

Despite the differences in optimal exercise duration between men and women, the study reaffirms the universal importance of regular physical activity for all adults. Regular exercise reduces mortality risk, regardless of gender. It is a powerful tool in maintaining overall health and well-being, and it's never too late to start.

Identifying the Optimal Exercise Duration for Men and Women

For men, the maximum survival advantage was achieved with approximately five hours per week of moderate to vigorous aerobic physical activity, such as brisk walking or cycling. On the other hand, women gained the same survival benefit with just under 2 1/2 hours of exercise per week.

When it came to muscle-strengthening activities like weightlifting or core body exercises, men realized their peak benefit from three sessions per week, while women garnered the same amount of benefit from about one session per week.

Empowering Women Through Exercise

These findings serve as an empowerment tool for women, offering them a tangible understanding that they stand to gain significantly from each unit of regular exercise they incorporate into their long-term health plan.

Thus, it's essential that people remember that exercise training regimens out there are often written for men. It's that much more important for personal trainers to be aware of this bias and use their knowledge to tailor programming towards individual needs, but especially taking this research into account.

"Men gain a maximal survival advantage from 300 minutes of moderate to vigorous activity per week, whereas women obtain the same benefit from 140 minutes per week," said Martha Gulati, MD, director of Preventive Cardiology in the Department of Cardiology at the Smidt Heart Institute at Cedars-Sinai.

The study further found that women continue to reap additional benefits for up to 300 minutes a week. This pioneering research is a crucial step towards understanding gender-specific physiology in exercise-related clinical outcomes and could significantly influence future exercise guidelines.

This study serves as a vital reminder of the importance of physical activity for all, while also underscoring the unique benefits that women can derive from regular exercise.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.